If you look around the world, it isn't simple. It's not only complex, it's messy. I've said from the beginning that there aren't easy answers.
Life is complex. Simple living is not the same as over simplification. As simple systems evolve and coevolve they form complex systems. There is a richness in complexity and nature, for all its simplicity, glories in complexity. If we are going to create a society that is anything other than stark and uniform, it is going to have to be complex.
Complexity isn't a good thing or a bad thing, it just is. As such we need to find a way of dealing with it and enjoying it. We need to be able to embrace the world in its many facets and complicated riches.
Complexity theory (see my post of 7/16/08) is one way to embrace the chaos. Complexity theory talks about 'Complex Adaptive Systems'. It's system theory brought into the twenty-first century.
Complexity tends to organize itself. If you look you can see systems everywhere. Systems adapt, cope, develop, and emerge. A quote that sticks in my mind is "You can't manage a system, a system manages a system." Embracing complexity doesn't mean we control it. As a person I was speaking to recently put it: "You can influence systems, you can't control them."
Some of these systems are rather destructive. While it is necessary to oppose the destructive aspects, it's not clear that we can destroy these systems. Buckminister Fuller said, "You never change things by fighting the existing reality. To change something, build a new model that makes the existing model obsolete". Or as the IWW put it, "we are forming the structure of the new society within the shell of the old."
Thus we need to create new systems. The systems we create will be simple (at first). If they work, they will become complex and out of our control. We need to embrace what works and replace what doesn't. And learn to ride on the waves of complexity.
Quote of the day: "Abandon the urge to simplify everything, to look for formulas and easy answers, and to begin to think multidimensionally, to glory in the mystery and paradoxes of life, not to be dismayed by the multitude of causes and consequences that are inherent in each experience -- to appreciate the fact that life is complex." - M. Scott Peck
Word (or phrase) of the day: Anarchist Law
Hero(es) of the day: Henry David Thoreau
Sunday, October 26, 2008
Friday, October 24, 2008
CDIP
There are many things that I like about this society. I actually appreciate the complexity and diversity we have here. I also like the openness to individuality. Simple, Egalitarian, Communal, and Sustainable is all very well, but I also want a world that is Complex, Diverse, Individual, and Practical. Is this a contradiction?
I've thought about it, but I don't think so. The Amish have seemed SECSy to me (although I've heard that they are more hierarchical than they appear), but I don't really want to live in an Amish world. (I doubt that they'd be very appreciative of bi/poly folks, for example, not to mention pagan.) I like the complexity and diversity, the messiness of this world. I enjoy being different and want a world that appreciates individuality. I want a society that offers more options to people, not less. And I think that all this is compatible with simple, egalitarian, communal, and sustainable. I also want all this to be practical--idealistic, yes, but practical as well.
Does this sound crazy or contradictory? Stay with me while I explore complexity, diversity, individuality, and practicality, and I will get to the contradictions.
Quote of the day: "Sometimes I've believed as many as six impossible things before breakfast." - Lewis Carroll
Word (or phrase) of the day: Breeder
Hero(es) of the day: Fernando Pereira
I've thought about it, but I don't think so. The Amish have seemed SECSy to me (although I've heard that they are more hierarchical than they appear), but I don't really want to live in an Amish world. (I doubt that they'd be very appreciative of bi/poly folks, for example, not to mention pagan.) I like the complexity and diversity, the messiness of this world. I enjoy being different and want a world that appreciates individuality. I want a society that offers more options to people, not less. And I think that all this is compatible with simple, egalitarian, communal, and sustainable. I also want all this to be practical--idealistic, yes, but practical as well.
Does this sound crazy or contradictory? Stay with me while I explore complexity, diversity, individuality, and practicality, and I will get to the contradictions.
Quote of the day: "Sometimes I've believed as many as six impossible things before breakfast." - Lewis Carroll
Word (or phrase) of the day: Breeder
Hero(es) of the day: Fernando Pereira
Labels:
Complexity,
Diversity,
Individuality,
Practicality
Wednesday, October 22, 2008
Egalitarian Communities
Living simply, equally, communally, and sustainably isn't just a nice ideal--there are people doing it. I mentioned the Amish in my last post but there are more modern groups that live even closer to this ideal.
I want to single out the Federation of Egalitarian Communities. These are six intentional communities based on the principles of: Holding land, labor, income, and other resources in common; Assuming responsibility for the needs of their members; Practicing non-violence; Using a form of decision making in which members have an equal opportunity to participate; Actively working to establish the equality of all people; Acting to conserve natural resources for present and future generations while striving to continually improve ecological awareness and practice; and Creating processes for group communication and participation and while providing an environment which supports people's development.
Obviously these communities practice cooperation and communal living. In fact, they are some of the more communal communities, sharing work, income, and resources.
They are also egalitarian, as reflected in the name. As they put it, they work "to establish the equality of all people". There are no gurus or set leaders--instead they rotate leadership. Even Twin Oaks, which has a Planner-Manager system, is hardly hierarchical. As Kat Kinkade explained, in her book Is It Utopia Yet?, "On the surface our system looks like a hierarchy, workers reporting to Managers and Managers to Planners. In practice the system is largely non-hierarchical. Nobody 'reports' to anybody.... The theory behind the design of our management system is that it is desirable to spread authority as broadly as possible. We tend to attract people who distrust hierarchies and want to cooperate with, rather than report to, other Community members.
"Furthermore, we're all 'workers', and at least three quarters of us are managers in addition." It's not exactly what Bruce Kokopeli and George Lakey had in mind in "Leadership for Change" (see my post of 10/2/08), but it is shared leadership.
As for sustainability, their principle on conserving "natural resources for present and future generations" is clear enough. In addition, several of the communities describe themselves as 'eco-villages'.
Simple living is not so explicit (except in the Emma Goldman Finishing School which lists 'simplicity' as one of their principles) but no one in any of these communities is getting rich. (There is a cartoon in Is It Utopia Yet where a character gets their allowance and says "You know, this is probably one of the few places left in the country where 'another day, another dollar' isn't just a saying.") Because they live communally, FEC members can live simply.
You can learn more about the Federation of Egalitarian Communities from their website. Kat Kinkade's books, Is It Utopia Yet? and the earlier A Walden Two Experiment are good sources to learn more about Twin Oaks--sort of the flagship FEC community. For those who think this kind of thing would never work, Twin Oaks has been around for forty-one years and it's going strong. Another triumph for SECS.
Next, a different way of looking at things.
Quote of the day: "A new way of living is not only possible, it is happening now!" - from the FEC website
Word (or phrase) of the day: Green Roofs
Hero(es) of the day: Mary McLeod Bethune
I want to single out the Federation of Egalitarian Communities. These are six intentional communities based on the principles of: Holding land, labor, income, and other resources in common; Assuming responsibility for the needs of their members; Practicing non-violence; Using a form of decision making in which members have an equal opportunity to participate; Actively working to establish the equality of all people; Acting to conserve natural resources for present and future generations while striving to continually improve ecological awareness and practice; and Creating processes for group communication and participation and while providing an environment which supports people's development.
Obviously these communities practice cooperation and communal living. In fact, they are some of the more communal communities, sharing work, income, and resources.
They are also egalitarian, as reflected in the name. As they put it, they work "to establish the equality of all people". There are no gurus or set leaders--instead they rotate leadership. Even Twin Oaks, which has a Planner-Manager system, is hardly hierarchical. As Kat Kinkade explained, in her book Is It Utopia Yet?, "On the surface our system looks like a hierarchy, workers reporting to Managers and Managers to Planners. In practice the system is largely non-hierarchical. Nobody 'reports' to anybody.... The theory behind the design of our management system is that it is desirable to spread authority as broadly as possible. We tend to attract people who distrust hierarchies and want to cooperate with, rather than report to, other Community members.
"Furthermore, we're all 'workers', and at least three quarters of us are managers in addition." It's not exactly what Bruce Kokopeli and George Lakey had in mind in "Leadership for Change" (see my post of 10/2/08), but it is shared leadership.
As for sustainability, their principle on conserving "natural resources for present and future generations" is clear enough. In addition, several of the communities describe themselves as 'eco-villages'.
Simple living is not so explicit (except in the Emma Goldman Finishing School which lists 'simplicity' as one of their principles) but no one in any of these communities is getting rich. (There is a cartoon in Is It Utopia Yet where a character gets their allowance and says "You know, this is probably one of the few places left in the country where 'another day, another dollar' isn't just a saying.") Because they live communally, FEC members can live simply.
You can learn more about the Federation of Egalitarian Communities from their website. Kat Kinkade's books, Is It Utopia Yet? and the earlier A Walden Two Experiment are good sources to learn more about Twin Oaks--sort of the flagship FEC community. For those who think this kind of thing would never work, Twin Oaks has been around for forty-one years and it's going strong. Another triumph for SECS.
Next, a different way of looking at things.
Quote of the day: "A new way of living is not only possible, it is happening now!" - from the FEC website
Word (or phrase) of the day: Green Roofs
Hero(es) of the day: Mary McLeod Bethune
Monday, October 20, 2008
Interconnections
I see these four principles (SECS as I call them) as being interconnected and intersupportive.
Simple living is sustainable living. In order to live sustainably, we need to live simply. As we need and use less, we also allow those who don't have to have more, thus moving toward equality.
Living cooperatively and/or communally allows you to share stuff, which means you can live more simply and sustainably. It also mean that those who share have somewhat of an equal access to stuff, reducing the disparities between people.
Income sharing communities are consciously egalitarian. In fact, the main organization of income-sharing communities is called The Federation of Egalitarian Communities.
Egalitarian is only sustainable if it's simple. As many people have put it, if everyone lived the way that the average American lives we'd need several planets worth of resources. We can get away with living so unsustainably now because of how unequal our consumption is. A simple life is the only life that promotes equality and sustainability--and cooperative and/or communal sharing can help us live simply.
To see how these are all connected, I'll quote from an interview with Oren Lyons, the 'faithkeeper' of the Onondaga Nation. He was speaking with Tim Knauss, of the Syracuse (New York) Post-Standard, about the traditions of the Haudenosaunee, or the Six Nations of the Iroquois Confederacy. One of these traditions is the oft-cited admonition to consider the seventh generation to come in every decision you make. (In other words, make decisions that will be sustainable.)
Lyons talked about Sen. Henry Dawes, of Massachusetts. Dawes sponsored legislation (the Dawes Act) which broke up the collectively owned Indian land, because he thought Indians needed individual ownership in order to become successful.
Lyons claimed that Dawes said that "I just came back from the Cherokee Nation ... in Oklahoma. Well, he said... they had schools, there was no war, they had their statehouse, they were living communally. They were very happy, he said, if not blissful there. They were all working like an Indian community. And he says, and that's the problem.... He says, well, as you know, if somebody is living in those terms, they're not going to progress. They're just going to be happy just the way they are. There'll be no progress....
"I think he said. ... the bottom line of our civilization was selfishness. We have to teach them to be selfish, so they can progress. ... It's about progress."
Here's an example of SECS, where the Cherokees (and other tribes) were living simply, communally, sustainably, and to a large degree, equally. And it was deliberately destroyed because of someone's ideal of 'progress' and the notion that we need selfishness and greed in order to progress.
But SECS isn't enough. Now, to make things more complex, I want to put out a set of principles that may at first seem to contradict my principles of Simplicity, Equality, Community, and Sustainability. I think, though, they complement them.
But first, let me give a living example of what I think is interconnected SECS.
Quote of the day: "When a system is whole and healthy, when it is based on relationships of interdependence and cooperation that further resilience, diversity, abundance, sustainability, creativity, and freedom, it exhibits that balance that we humans call 'justice'." - Starhawk
Word (or phrase) of the day: Co-Intelligence
Hero(es) of the day: Judi Bari
Simple living is sustainable living. In order to live sustainably, we need to live simply. As we need and use less, we also allow those who don't have to have more, thus moving toward equality.
Living cooperatively and/or communally allows you to share stuff, which means you can live more simply and sustainably. It also mean that those who share have somewhat of an equal access to stuff, reducing the disparities between people.
Income sharing communities are consciously egalitarian. In fact, the main organization of income-sharing communities is called The Federation of Egalitarian Communities.
Egalitarian is only sustainable if it's simple. As many people have put it, if everyone lived the way that the average American lives we'd need several planets worth of resources. We can get away with living so unsustainably now because of how unequal our consumption is. A simple life is the only life that promotes equality and sustainability--and cooperative and/or communal sharing can help us live simply.
To see how these are all connected, I'll quote from an interview with Oren Lyons, the 'faithkeeper' of the Onondaga Nation. He was speaking with Tim Knauss, of the Syracuse (New York) Post-Standard, about the traditions of the Haudenosaunee, or the Six Nations of the Iroquois Confederacy. One of these traditions is the oft-cited admonition to consider the seventh generation to come in every decision you make. (In other words, make decisions that will be sustainable.)
Lyons talked about Sen. Henry Dawes, of Massachusetts. Dawes sponsored legislation (the Dawes Act) which broke up the collectively owned Indian land, because he thought Indians needed individual ownership in order to become successful.
Lyons claimed that Dawes said that "I just came back from the Cherokee Nation ... in Oklahoma. Well, he said... they had schools, there was no war, they had their statehouse, they were living communally. They were very happy, he said, if not blissful there. They were all working like an Indian community. And he says, and that's the problem.... He says, well, as you know, if somebody is living in those terms, they're not going to progress. They're just going to be happy just the way they are. There'll be no progress....
"I think he said. ... the bottom line of our civilization was selfishness. We have to teach them to be selfish, so they can progress. ... It's about progress."
Here's an example of SECS, where the Cherokees (and other tribes) were living simply, communally, sustainably, and to a large degree, equally. And it was deliberately destroyed because of someone's ideal of 'progress' and the notion that we need selfishness and greed in order to progress.
But SECS isn't enough. Now, to make things more complex, I want to put out a set of principles that may at first seem to contradict my principles of Simplicity, Equality, Community, and Sustainability. I think, though, they complement them.
But first, let me give a living example of what I think is interconnected SECS.
Quote of the day: "When a system is whole and healthy, when it is based on relationships of interdependence and cooperation that further resilience, diversity, abundance, sustainability, creativity, and freedom, it exhibits that balance that we humans call 'justice'." - Starhawk
Word (or phrase) of the day: Co-Intelligence
Hero(es) of the day: Judi Bari
Saturday, October 18, 2008
Sustainable Resources
As I mentioned in my initial post on sustainability (10/14/08), this is a hot topic. There are lots of resources available. In fact, there is at least one whole publishing house (Chelsea Green), and possibly more, devoted to publishing books on sustainability. I will just mention a few resources here.
In my post on Appropriate Technology (8/19/08) I listed two books which I will list again: Nancy Jack Todd's A Safe and Sustainable World: The Promise of Ecological Design, and the Farallones Institute's classic, The Integral Urban House. Another useful book is the Toolbox for Sustainable City Living by Stacy Pettigrew and Scott Kellogg (co-founders of the Rhizome Collective in Austin, Texas)--this just published book looks like an updated version of the information from the previous two books with a Do-It-Yourself (or better yet, as they say as well as my dear friends Ellie and Jules say, Do-It-Ourselves) mentality. I'm reading it now and it's amazing.
A couple of websites with sustainable resources include the Sustainable Communities Network and Sustainable Sources . For those interested in designing sustainably, a site called Sustainable by Design offers shareware design tools.
Of course, the Transition Initiative (which I talked about in my last post) is a major resource for sustainability.
Next, the interconnections...
Quote of the day: "The future is literally in our hands to mold as we like. But we cannot wait until tomorrow. Tomorrow is now." - Eleanor Roosevelt
Word (or phrase) of the day: Open Space Technology
Hero(es) of the day: Ernst Bloch
In my post on Appropriate Technology (8/19/08) I listed two books which I will list again: Nancy Jack Todd's A Safe and Sustainable World: The Promise of Ecological Design, and the Farallones Institute's classic, The Integral Urban House. Another useful book is the Toolbox for Sustainable City Living by Stacy Pettigrew and Scott Kellogg (co-founders of the Rhizome Collective in Austin, Texas)--this just published book looks like an updated version of the information from the previous two books with a Do-It-Yourself (or better yet, as they say as well as my dear friends Ellie and Jules say, Do-It-Ourselves) mentality. I'm reading it now and it's amazing.
A couple of websites with sustainable resources include the Sustainable Communities Network and Sustainable Sources . For those interested in designing sustainably, a site called Sustainable by Design offers shareware design tools.
Of course, the Transition Initiative (which I talked about in my last post) is a major resource for sustainability.
Next, the interconnections...
Quote of the day: "The future is literally in our hands to mold as we like. But we cannot wait until tomorrow. Tomorrow is now." - Eleanor Roosevelt
Word (or phrase) of the day: Open Space Technology
Hero(es) of the day: Ernst Bloch
Thursday, October 16, 2008
Transition Towns
The Transition Towns movement started when Rob Hopkins held a permaculture (see my post of 7/22/08) course in Kinsale, Ireland. As part of the course, students created an "Energy Descent Action Plan". One of the students took it to the town council which resulted in the town of Kinsale adopting the plan. Rob Hopkins, inspired by this, took the idea to his hometown of Totnes, England, which eventually became an official Transition Town.
At this point there are one hundred locations, worldwide, officially embracing a Transition Initiative (the name that will be slowly replacing 'Transition Town' since many of the locations are cities, villages, districts, etc). In addition, there are well over six hundred locations across the planet that are 'mulling over' the idea.
The Transition Initiative is a formal process that involves a commitment from everyone involved. It begins when there are four or five people willing to step into leadership roles (the Transition folks are clear that one or two enthusiastic persons are not enough). They have a twelve step process (yes, like a recovery group) that they outline for developing the initiative--from setting up a steering group that begins with the intention to disband as soon as sub-groups are formed, to creating an Energy Descent Plan. (And one of the steps is to use Open Space Technology. See my post of 8/31/08, which includes a bit about Transition Towns.)
Rob Hopkins has written a book called The Transition Handbook which outlines the Transition Initiative process which is available from the Transition Culture website. There is also a Transition Primer available for free on the Transition Towns WIKI which is also a great source for all sorts of information on Transition Initiatives. Finally, there are Transition Trainings happening in England, the US, Canada, Italy, New Zealand, and provisionally, Australia and Japan. I am very pleased that several will be happening in the Boston area, as well as up in Portland, Maine.
If you are interested in taking sustainability beyond your household, this is the next step up. We may not be able to change the nations yet (let alone the world), but you may be able to make your town (city, village, district, etc) a Transition Town.
Quote of the day: "People are starting to see peak oil as the Great Opportunity, the chance to build the world they always dreamt of. ... The scale of the challenge is huge, and the obstacles are plenty, but there is an emerging energy to succeed, a sense of quickening and an exhilaration in talking and listening to each other once again, to visioning what we want and then rolling up our sleeves and starting to co-create it." - Rob Hopkins
Word (or phrase) of the day: Sustainable Agriculture
Hero(es) of the day: Maggie Kuhn
At this point there are one hundred locations, worldwide, officially embracing a Transition Initiative (the name that will be slowly replacing 'Transition Town' since many of the locations are cities, villages, districts, etc). In addition, there are well over six hundred locations across the planet that are 'mulling over' the idea.
The Transition Initiative is a formal process that involves a commitment from everyone involved. It begins when there are four or five people willing to step into leadership roles (the Transition folks are clear that one or two enthusiastic persons are not enough). They have a twelve step process (yes, like a recovery group) that they outline for developing the initiative--from setting up a steering group that begins with the intention to disband as soon as sub-groups are formed, to creating an Energy Descent Plan. (And one of the steps is to use Open Space Technology. See my post of 8/31/08, which includes a bit about Transition Towns.)
Rob Hopkins has written a book called The Transition Handbook which outlines the Transition Initiative process which is available from the Transition Culture website. There is also a Transition Primer available for free on the Transition Towns WIKI which is also a great source for all sorts of information on Transition Initiatives. Finally, there are Transition Trainings happening in England, the US, Canada, Italy, New Zealand, and provisionally, Australia and Japan. I am very pleased that several will be happening in the Boston area, as well as up in Portland, Maine.
If you are interested in taking sustainability beyond your household, this is the next step up. We may not be able to change the nations yet (let alone the world), but you may be able to make your town (city, village, district, etc) a Transition Town.
Quote of the day: "People are starting to see peak oil as the Great Opportunity, the chance to build the world they always dreamt of. ... The scale of the challenge is huge, and the obstacles are plenty, but there is an emerging energy to succeed, a sense of quickening and an exhilaration in talking and listening to each other once again, to visioning what we want and then rolling up our sleeves and starting to co-create it." - Rob Hopkins
Word (or phrase) of the day: Sustainable Agriculture
Hero(es) of the day: Maggie Kuhn
Labels:
Community,
Ecology,
Social Change,
Sustainability
Tuesday, October 14, 2008
Sustainability
Sustainability, like Simplicity, Equality, Community, and Cooperation, has multiple meanings. It's become very popular these days, to the point that some people refer to it as a meaningless 'buzz word'. At the very least, it refers to both the way that ecosystems work and the way we need to live.
As far as I'm concerned, sustainability means that whatever we build needs to be for the long-term. It means we see ourselves as part of the web of nature and act accordingly. It means that we use only renewable natural resources and use them as little as possible, allowing them to replenish themselves. It also means that we think about what works and what doesn't, as well as thinking about the future and what we leave to those who come after us. The Environmental Protection Agency defines sustainability as "meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs." We need to think ahead. Thinking 'to the seventh generation' is a good start, but we may need to think beyond that.
In my post of 8/27/08, on Fritjof Capra's The Hidden Connections, I listed his basic principles of ecology, including "... an ecosystem generates no waste, one species' waste being another species' food." Generating no waste is also part of being sustainable. Nothing goes to waste, everything is reused--sometimes by recycling or, even better, composting--where what we see as wastes become food for plants. Sustainability means being creative, figuring out how to use less and waste nothing.
This ties in with living simply, since simple living uses less stuff. It ties in with living communally, since sharing things again means we need less and therefore there's more to go around and it lasts longer. But it also means that as we try to be Simple and Egalitarian and Communal we do it in such a way that we don't burn ourselves out. We are trying to build a society that lasts.
Next: Transitioning
Quote of the day: "... one of our main responsibilities is to leave to successor generations a sustainable future." - UN Secretary-General Kofi A. Annan
Word (or phrase) of the day: Eco-socialism
Hero(es) of the day: Harry Simms (Kentucky)
As far as I'm concerned, sustainability means that whatever we build needs to be for the long-term. It means we see ourselves as part of the web of nature and act accordingly. It means that we use only renewable natural resources and use them as little as possible, allowing them to replenish themselves. It also means that we think about what works and what doesn't, as well as thinking about the future and what we leave to those who come after us. The Environmental Protection Agency defines sustainability as "meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs." We need to think ahead. Thinking 'to the seventh generation' is a good start, but we may need to think beyond that.
In my post of 8/27/08, on Fritjof Capra's The Hidden Connections, I listed his basic principles of ecology, including "... an ecosystem generates no waste, one species' waste being another species' food." Generating no waste is also part of being sustainable. Nothing goes to waste, everything is reused--sometimes by recycling or, even better, composting--where what we see as wastes become food for plants. Sustainability means being creative, figuring out how to use less and waste nothing.
This ties in with living simply, since simple living uses less stuff. It ties in with living communally, since sharing things again means we need less and therefore there's more to go around and it lasts longer. But it also means that as we try to be Simple and Egalitarian and Communal we do it in such a way that we don't burn ourselves out. We are trying to build a society that lasts.
Next: Transitioning
Quote of the day: "... one of our main responsibilities is to leave to successor generations a sustainable future." - UN Secretary-General Kofi A. Annan
Word (or phrase) of the day: Eco-socialism
Hero(es) of the day: Harry Simms (Kentucky)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)